Why the Celtics Should Stop Thinking About a Traditional Rebuild
The textbook says bottom out, collect picks and wait. Danny Ainge and Brad Stevens have a better option, and the Isaiah Thomas trade proves it.
The traditional rebuild goes like this: trade your veterans, lose as many games as you can, hope the lottery is kind, and draft a franchise player. Then wait three or four years for him to grow up. The Celtics have been told for two seasons now that this is their path. It is time to stop pretending it is the only one.
Boston already has the assets
The reason teams tank is to get draft picks. The Celtics already have plenty of them. The 2013 trade that sent Paul Pierce and Kevin Garnett to Brooklyn handed Danny Ainge control of a string of future Nets picks, and Ainge has been adding more from other deals ever since. Boston does not need to be terrible to stock up. It has already done the stocking.
That changes the maths. A team without picks has to lose to get them. A team with a war chest of picks can afford to try to get better now and still keep its long-term options open.
Brad Stevens is a reason to compete
The other thing a traditional rebuild ignores is the coach. Stevens has spent this season getting more out of a roster without a star than anyone had a right to expect. His teams play hard, move the ball and compete every night. Asking a coach like that to preside over a planned 60-loss season would waste the one thing Boston clearly has right.
Young players also learn more in competitive games than in seasons where nobody cares about the result. Marcus Smart, the rookie, is already showing he belongs in close games. Let him play some that matter.
The Isaiah Thomas trade is the right model
At the deadline this week Ainge traded for Isaiah Thomas, a scorer on a team-friendly contract who has been an afterthought in Phoenix. It is exactly the kind of move a team in a traditional rebuild would not make. Thomas is 26, not 19. He makes the Celtics better this season.
And that is fine. The East is weak enough that a team around .500 can contend for a playoff spot. A playoff series, even a short one, would be valuable for this group and a selling point for the free agents Ainge wants to talk to this summer.
What the alternative looks like
| Approach | Cost | Upside |
|---|---|---|
| Traditional tank | Years of losing, a culture to rebuild later | One high pick, with lottery luck |
| Compete and collect | Lower own pick | A winning culture, flexible assets, a better pitch to stars |
The objection
The honest counter-argument is that stars win in the NBA, and the easiest way to get one is the top of the draft. That is true. But the Celtics’ best path to a star may be the Brooklyn picks, a trade using its stockpile, or free agency — none of which requires Boston to lose on purpose.
The traditional rebuild was the right idea for a team with nothing. The Celtics are not a team with nothing anymore.
Looking back: Boston finished 40–42 that season, made the playoffs as the seventh seed and were swept by Cleveland. Thomas became an All-Star, the Nets picks turned into Jaylen Brown and Jayson Tatum, and the Celtics never went through a full tank.