What Would the Celtics Need to Get in on Ben Simmons?
Ben Simmons wants out of Philadelphia and Daryl Morey wants a star. Here is what a realistic Celtics offer would look like, and why it probably never happens.
Short answer: a lot more than the Celtics should be willing to give. Ben Simmons has not played for Philadelphia this season, the 76ers have made clear they want a star-level return, and Boston’s only player who clearly meets that bar outside Jayson Tatum is Jaylen Brown. Neither is going anywhere for Simmons. But the question is worth working through, because it shows where this roster stands.
The salary problem
Simmons is in the early years of a max extension, earning more than $30 million this season. Under NBA trade rules, a team over the cap has to send out roughly matching salary to take him on. For Boston, that means any package starts with one big contract or several mid-sized ones.
Look down the payroll and the options are limited. Tatum and Brown are the core. Al Horford’s contract is a possibility in pure salary terms. Marcus Smart signed an extension before the season. After that, it is a collection of smaller deals that do not add up to Simmons money without gutting the rotation.
The Philadelphia problem
Even if the money worked, the 76ers have no reason to take back veterans and picks. Daryl Morey’s position, as widely reported, has been that he will wait for a deal that brings back an All-Star. Trading a franchise talent inside the division to a long-time rival is not something any front office does lightly, either.
A thought experiment
If you set Brown aside, the most plausible Boston framework would look something like this:
- A veteran contract for salary matching
- One or more young players with upside, such as Robert Williams or Payton Pritchard
- Multiple future first-round picks and swaps
That is a heavy price for a player who, for all his defensive brilliance and passing, remains a non-shooter on a roster that already struggles for spacing. Put Simmons next to Tatum, Brown and Smart and opponents would happily pack the paint.
Does Simmons even fit?
On defence, absolutely. Simmons can guard almost anyone, and Ime Udoka’s switching scheme would love him. On offence, the fit is awkward. The Celtics need ball movement and shooting around their two wings. Simmons is a brilliant transition player, but in a half-court playoff game his reluctance to shoot is a problem every opponent has already exploited.
The verdict
Boston is better off giving this group time. It is early, the team is figuring out a new coach, and the most important development of the season will be Tatum and Brown learning to make each other better. The Simmons saga is great theatre. It is not the Celtics’ fight.
Update: Philadelphia traded Simmons to Brooklyn in February 2022 in the deal that sent James Harden to the 76ers. The Celtics, without a blockbuster, went on to reach the 2022 NBA Finals.